POST-INDEPENDENCE VALUES

 

By BASUDHA CHAKRAVARTY

 

The political independence of which the people of India dreamt, and for which they fought and suffered, could well have been expected to generate a moral and spiritual enthusiasm indicative of a rebirth. It seems just the opposite has happened. After the first flush of joy spent itself out, people began to complain of disillusionment. There were even those, very few in number, who dared say the old days had been better. But even the vast masses of people find themselves nowhere near the El Dorado into which they had thought, freedom would transform their country.

 

Yet independence has affected our sense of values in the shape of a yearning for greater realisation and fulfillment of life. There is of course around us enough evidence of sordid satisfaction with material gain; but that satisfaction would not have appeared sordid except to sensitive minds yearning for something more tangible and abiding. Before independence, the struggle for independence satisfied the people’s need of idealism. All moral and spiritual values were requisitioned by the aspiration for independence. Thousands of people dedicated their lives. Countless careers were sacrificed, and innumerable families were involved in ruin in freedom’s cause. Ideals of sacrifice and dedication ruled. The contrast with that idyllic state of things is all the more glaring in the self-seeking apparently prevalent today. Freedom and independence, one cannot avoid feeling, should have immediately raised our mental and moral level. But let that alone, even the ideals of living and suffering for one’s country which prevailed so short a while ago are today hardly to be met with. When values have admittedly gone topsy-turvy, a sense of infinite values is awaking. It is a sense of self-transcending realisation, of abiding fulfillment of life, of a quest of immortality. To describe it thus is to tread on dangerously emotional ground. But that is the apt way to describe the subtle working of purposeful minds.

 

In West Bengal particularly, the yearning for some standard of values is real indeed. It is not difficult to trace that yearning to the mortifying and first-hand experience of partition and the persona1 and collective cataclysm it has caused. Partition might have been a political necessity and historically even pre-determined, but that cannot gloss over the incalculable material and emotional damage it brought in its wake. Friends have had to be parted, families have suffered, individuals have gone into the wilderness. None should run away with the idea that this sense of loss is not reciprocated by sensitive minds in East Bengal. Even now a visit to some Chowringhee restaurant where their erstwhile associates are known to congregate, has the first place on the programmes of visitors from Dacca. All this is the index of a desire to transcend reality, to transcend oneself unto a scheme of things where life has some assurance of ordered fulfillment, some progress conducive to happiness.

 

Not long ago this feeling sought a ready refuge in Communism. Therein however a recession seems to have occurred, partly because of the impression caused by events in Communist countries that Communism has reached its anti-thesis in the suppression of human individuality, and partly because Communists at home have been doing too much with makeshifts even in passing political matters to offer any free and assured outlet for the overweening urges of life. And then hope derived out of schemes of development embodied in the Five Year Plans has begun to fill the vacuum that Communism has ultimately failed to fill. Criticism from adverse sources is often traceable to an inferiority complex in regard to achievements that cannot be denied. If only through expansion of industrial activity and community projects in rural areas, the development plans have begun to infiltrate into men’s lives. There is still much unemployment; standards of living have not gone perceptibly high. Yet there is greater security of living, greater diffusion of opportunity than before. Also there has been an ideological accession to the concept of freedom. The very fact that the official policy of the country has steered clear not only of conflicting ideologies but of the two ideological world blocs, has imparted a sense of additional personal freedom. What passes under the general name of Gandhism sets the background for untrammelled, unobtrusive acquaintance with life. Altogether the mental stage is set for a really humanistic outlook on men and things. Historically speaking also the avowed secular nature of the State has, as it were, canalised the stream of life in accord with the synthetic civilisation of which our past in arts and architecture bears so much evidence. For individual minds also it has been a release and a relief. The scope it has left for the free quest of knowledge and life has served as a compensation for all the stress and strain communalism and the resultant partition of the country have caused. The organised efforts undertaken by the Government to further the pursuit of the arts and the sciences have also given a fillip to individual and collective urges to that end. The recent revival and culture of classical music is an example. A sense of unity and uniformity also pervades the progress in all these spheres in different parts of the country. Politically also the very broad canvas of civil liberty under which life in the country is allowed to function, the protection such liberty has received at the hands of the judiciary, and the public vigil over civil rights and liberties preserves a mood of moral and physical reassurance. There is of course no gainsaying that individual option both in ideological and behavourist spheres will depend on the success of the measures for an equitable readjustment of society unto full individual right and freedom. The number of people who believe that it is possible of realisation on ordered, evolutionary lines, and that within the confines of the present socio-economic system, is still not large.

 

Meanwhile however hope of a steady way of life emerging out of the somewhat haphazard plans with which the nation is groping, already impinges on the sense of frustration and un-fulfillment that grew deplorably early in the wake of independence. It is remarkable that the very fact that our country and our Prime Minister are steering clear of dogmatic ideologies and have actually given a sort of lead in favour of the co-existence of ideologies, has served to direct our outlook on humanity at large rather than on any specific social system. There are those who think that this approach will get bogged in the present system. But we are not in a static system either, and far-reaching social and economic reforms have been taken in hand. It remains to be seen whether these are of the right type and adequate, and whether they will succeed in placing the individual in proper relation to society without impinging on his freedom. Today however the emphasis is on the individual man and woman. It is they that have been asked to find their fulfillment in collective endeavour. The response is not very spectacular. It is also circumscribed by the self-centred outlook largely prevalent today. Slowly but surely the prospect opens before young men and women of integration with the stream of human civilisation and of efforts at contribution thereto. It explains the increasing sale and study of foreign literature, the widening desire to learn and study foreign languages and to go abroad. It would be crude to ascribe all this to a desire to advance personal careers. Personal careers wait to be adjusted and assimilated unto a general movement towards self-discovery and progress in the country and the world. Hence we find around us many examples of concentrated effort at development, of determined endeavour to fall in line with the progress of human knowledge and civilisation. We are increasingly reaching out for cultural exchange with other countries and incorporating their music and literature into our intimate lives. Today our passions and strivings, stresses and tensions throb in unison with movements in the wide world. In all this we feel we have again found some meaning in our lives. It is for the State and Society to harness every bit of energy on well-ordered lines and to build up a social organism calculated to achieve that end. If, on the other band, social inequality persists in its present form, the resultant imbalance will endanger all chances of ordered procedure. But to the extent that there is a purposeful drive against suffering, and an attempt to transcend it into creative effort in all compartments of life, there is hope.

 

Back